Over twenty years ago, D. A. Carson published his volume entitled Exegeti- cal Fallacies (Grand Rapids: Baker, ). In it he covers the areas of word-study. This book offers updated explanations of the sins of interpretation to teach sound grammatical, lexical, cultural, theological, and historical Bible study practices. “In short, this is an amateur’s collection of exegetical fallacies” (p). In this book, D.A. Carson seeks to reveal the numerous Exegetical Fallacies that occur from.
|Published (Last):||1 June 2008|
|PDF File Size:||5.35 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||1.24 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
These errors are often discussed without context, so that Carson is not sensitive to what his errorsome colleagues might be trying to do in a larger sense. There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
This chapter will prove helpful to second year Greek students in the vital task of bridging the gap between morphology and context. I really do respect the authors I’m critiquing and their works are, overall, extremely valuable.
Jun 12, Kenneth Trax rated it it was amazing. The difference between exegesis and hermeneutics p.
Exegetical Fallacies: D. A. Carson: : Books
Would you like to tell us about a lower price? A brilliant little book that I will have to return to again.
He is one of the founders of The Gospel Coalition and an active guest lecturer in academic and church settings around the world. Historical reconstructions are an effort of specialists to recover information about culture, events, people, and places in an attempt to fill in gaps in understanding the ancient world.
In the third chapter, Carson tackles the problem of faulty logic. There are only a couple thi This was quite a good book and I am glad to have read it.
Each fallacy points to an error in the way the interpreter lets their preunderstanding taint their view of the text or the way the interpreter shapes historical renderings to suit their perspective or support and agree with prior conclusions. That’s about where I am in my Greek, so I appreciated all the warnings!
Get to Know Us. Shopbop Designer Fashion Brands. Amazon Renewed Refurbished products with a warranty. This book describes and categorizes many fallacies found in Biblical exegesis. Feb 22, Zack rated it really liked it.
He draws attention to the fact that while a statement may be true and an argument may be valid, these can still be insufficient means to prove a particular conclusion. Carson is clearly an exegete of uncommon skill, especially in his grasp of the general rules of linguistics and logic. It provides clear definitions and good illustrations, and is especially adept at distinguishing and relating the various “members” of the various families of fallaices fallacies.
That being said, it is a valuable reference—especially for readers who know a little Greek vocabulary, grammar and syntax. Customers who bought this item also bought. Unlike scientific experiments, historical events and people cannot be recreated. The first two chapters of this x are catson with many very eegetical linguistic fallacies that dog biblical exegetes of all stripes, and while I found ample information to be applied outside this narrow niche, I looked forward to the third chapter, dealing specifically with logical fallacies, as I hoped there would be even more there to apply to other ways of thinking.
Careless Appeal to Background Material— Using background information to formulate a fallacise for which there is little or no substantial connection or grounds for its validity. For what this book sets out to be, it’s fantastic.
Carson No preview available – And, more often than not, the error is in ignoring the context and investing undue authority in the words themselves. It warns us of the fallacies we are so easily prone to commit especially when we are trying to safe-guard a pet doctrineand it serves to help us better detect such fallacies in others. We also confirm this by looking at the Greek source [‘spoudason] which means “make haste, be diligent.
This chapter was probably carsno least helpful given the lack of Greek that I have had. East Dane Designer Men’s Fashion.
Jul 29, Daniel Mount rated it really liked it Shelves: Presuppositional and Historical Fallacies 5. There was in fact significant semantic range overlap with “phileo” due to homonymic clash between “kyneo” to kiss and “kyno” to impregnate. A Handbook for Students and Pastors 3rd Edition. Negative Inferences— Assuming that if a proposition is true, then the negative inference of that proposition must also be true. Osborne, The Hermeneutical Spiral: User Review – Flag as inappropriate The author of this book is D.
And maybe even in more places. Rather, it means that real knowledge is close to impossible if we fail to recognize our own assumptions, questions, interests, and biases; but if we recognize them and, in dialogue with the text, seek to make allowances for them, we will be better able to avoid confusing our own world-views with those of the biblical writers.
My favorite chapters were on logical fallacies and historical and presuppositional fallacies.